Flaws in Share Class Selection Technology Costs Large Firm Nearly $14 Million
The dually-registered IA/BD affiliate of a large investment bank agreed to reimburse clients over $12 Million and agreed to pay a $1.5 Million fine because its advertised system failed to recommend the most economical fund share classes. The respondent marketed an automated mutual fund share class selection system that purported to pick the least expensive share classes for certain retirement plan and charitable organization customers. The SEC asserts that the system had programming and design flaws and that the respondent failed to adequately test and validate whether the system worked as advertised. Over the course of a 7-year period, the respondent overcharged over 18,000 clients.
Automated compliance systems are helpful, but they are not a cure-all. Like any tool, a compliance technology is only as good as the people using it. Bad inputs cause bad outputs. Also, firms can’t just “set it and forget it,” hoping that the system works.