SEC Official Says that a Cryptocurrency is Not a Security, Absent a Sponsored Offering
The SEC’s Director of Corporation Finance, William Hinman, recently opined that cryptocurrencies themselves are not securities subject to SEC oversight, although undertakings operated by a central control group and targeted to passive third parties would constitute a securities offering. Absent a “central enterprise” such that the digital asset is sold only to be used to purchase a good or service available through the network on which it was created, Mr. Hinman would not apply the securities laws. Factors that transform an enterprise into an offering of securities include (i) a central group that promotes the offering and benefits and expends assets/effort to increase the value; (ii) the raising of funds in excess of what is necessary to establish a functional network; (iii) purchasers that seek a return in excess of the current market value; and (iv) a sales effort directed to the general public rather than users. Mr. Hinman announced that the Division would be willing to offer promoters more formal interpretive or no-action guidance to ensure legal comfort.
OUR TAKE: Mr. Hinman offers practical guidance and some clarity on how to apply decades-old precedent to modern cryptocurrency networks and offerings. We expect more guidance in the coming months from the other SEC divisions.