SEC Official Questions Registration Exemption for ETF Index Providers
The SEC’s Director of the Division of Investment Management, Dalia Blass, questioned whether ETF index providers should continue to claim a blanket exemption from investment adviser registration. Ms. Blass, acknowledging an exemption for publishers of broad-based indexes, asked whether providers of more narrow indexes should register as investment advisers especially where such providers create indexes for a single fund or take significant input from the fund sponsor. Ms. Blass cautioned “against assuming that the status of a provider can be determined based simply on its characterization as an index provider” and encouraged fund sponsors and index providers to “refresh your analysis if you are looking at a bespoke or narrowly focused index.” Ms. Blass also advised funds to consider disclosure implications of narrow indexes.
OUR TAKE: As a result of Ms. Blass’s speech, index providers should expect some hard questions from fund counsel and independent directors’ counsel as the lines blur between index creation and investment recommendations.